Give every builder the same written scope, then compare labour, materials, allowances, exclusions and VAT line by line. Ask each builder to clarify gaps in writing before comparing totals.
Five checks before choosing a quote
- Use one scope. List the work, finishes and who supplies each item. Share the same version with every builder.
- Mark what’s included. Check preparation, removal, waste disposal and making good. Mark each item included, excluded or unclear.
- Separate allowances. Record provisional amounts for items such as tiles or fittings. Ask how a higher or lower final cost will be handled.
- Compare what you would actually pay. Ask whether VAT is included or applicable and price any work you would have to arrange separately.
- Check the builder and agree milestones. Ask for recent references and put payment stages and how changes will be priced in writing.
Why can the lower quote cost more?
In an illustrative example, a £12,000 quote that excludes £1,500 of flooring and £500 of waste removal comes to £14,000 on a comparable basis. A £13,500 quote including both would be £500 lower, assuming both totals use the same VAT basis and cover the same work.
For a worked comparison and four printable worksheets, see Before You Say Yes to a Builder.
For seven quick checks before you accept a quote, use the free builder quote checklist.